Feds Launch Investigation Of Chopper 4 Crash
POSTED: 6:33 p.m. EDT May 4, 2004
UPDATED: 10:53 a.m. EDT May 7, 2004
NEW YORK -- Federal transportation officials began
investigating on Wednesday what caused a NewsChannel 4 helicopter to spin
out of control and crash on a Brooklyn rooftop, causing minor
injuries to the reporter and two pilots on board.
Reporter Andrew Torres and the pilots were in stable condition
at Brooklyn hospitals, a day after they had flown to the area to
cover a shooting for WNBC-TV. The careening chopper clipped a
four-story apartment building and then crashed in pieces onto the
neighboring two-story building.
The helicopter pilot had reported a "tail rotor failure" to
air traffic controllers at Kennedy International Airport moments
before the 6:21 p.m. crash, according to Jim Peters, a Federal
Aviation Administration spokesman.
Luke Schiada, a senior investigator for the National
Transportation Safety Board, said Wednesday that officials had not
identified a cause, but were interested in the pilot's report.
"We're obviously going to take a closer look at that," he
said.
The tail rotor, which essentially counteracts the force created
by the turning of the main rotor, could fail in several different
scenarios, aviation expert Walt Lamon said. He also said that a
tail rotor failure is generally not a problem that would be
identified during preflight inspection.
"Everyone in the industry will look at this for causes and ways
that this can be avoided," he said. Helicopters "have a good
safety record, it's a relatively safe activity, and there will be
efforts focused on making it safer because of this."
Investigators also will be examining footage of the crash shot
by another news station. The NTSB expects to issue a preliminary
report in about five days, and a final ruling in several months.
"We have a lot more work still to do and we don't want to jump
to any conclusions," Schiada told reporters during a briefing at
the crash site, where two other news helicopters circled overhead.
Cranes removed the mangled pieces of the WNBC-TV helicopter,
which was owned by Horsham Valley Airways, and placed them on
flatbed trucks Wednesday morning. The California-based company
refused to comment on the crash or give further information about
the three passengers, who are their employees.
Jill Nicolini, who covers traffic and breaking news each day
from a helicopter for WB11's "Morning News," said she was
shocked, when she saw the wreckage, that the passengers survived.
"It does make you aware that it can be a dangerous job, but if
you have a passion and love for flying like I do and you know how
statistically safe flying is, I'm confident," said Nicolini, who
is training for an airplane pilot's license.
There were 212 civilian helicopter crashes nationwide in 2003,
37 with fatalities, a slight increase from 2002, which saw 205
crashes, 26 that were fatal, according to the Helicopter
Association International, which compiles FAA and NTSB data.
In 1978, before a push during the 1980s to improve helicopter
safety, there were more than 300 crashes.
In 1986, Jane Dornacker, a traffic reporter for WNBC Radio in
New York, was killed when her helicopter crashed into the Hudson
River. The pilot was critically injured.
As the chopper plunged toward a pier, listeners heard Dornacker
scream at the pilot, "Hit the water! Hit the water!"
The Federal Aviation Administration later accused the helicopter
company of making faulty repairs. Dornacker's daughter reached a
$325,000 settlement with the owner and manufacturer of the
helicopter.
Earlier in 1986, Dornacker and another pilot escaped unharmed
when a WNBC traffic helicopter crashed into the Hackensack River in
New Jersey.
In December 1998, a WNBC-TV helicopter crashed in a shower of
sparks into the Passaic River in New Jersey. The pilot and a
reporter were pulled from the water by workers at a riverside plant
and suffered only cuts and bruises.
WNBC debuted television news via Chopper 4, April 18, 1995, on "Live at Five." It provides NewsChannel 4 with live aerial shots for up-to-the-minute coverage of breaking news
CHOPPER 4 CRASH ![]() CAUGHT ON TAPE (Above Pictures Courtesy WABC-TV) INVESTIGATION BEGINS (Above Pictures Courtesy WPIX-TV) VIRTUAL TOUR VIEWER MESSAGES |
© 2004 by WNBC.com The Associated Press contributed to this report. All rights reserved. This material may not be published, broadcast, rewritten or redistributed.







