wnbc.com
Friday, August 29, 2008, 8:32 pm
Search 
Search IBS  Search the Web
news
E-Mail News Alerts
Get breaking news, daily headlines and more.
More

Some N.J. Terror Suspects Had Past Run-Ins With Law

By Jonathan Dienst

POSTED: 3:11 pm EDT May 10, 2007
UPDATED: 5:16 pm EDT May 10, 2007

Several of the so-called "Fort Dix Six" had past run-ins with the law, ranging from low-level drug offenses to driving without a license, according to court records.


  • This story was originally broken by the NewsChannel 4 Investigative Team. Click here to read more of their stories.
  • Slideshow: 6 Arrested In Alleged Terror Plot

  • WNBC.com has obtained 44 pages of records from the Cherry Hill Municipal Court outlining some of the suspects' past legal issues.

    Suspect Dritan Duka has past arrests on charges of disorderly conduct and possession of drugs and drug paraphernalia. He also has six separate speeding and driving with a suspended license infractions, records show.

    Shain Duka has past arrests on charges of obstruction of justice, hindering apprehension and making physical threats. He also has five separate traffic infractions. Eljvir Duka has past drug counts and at least two motor vehicle infractions.

    The three brothers are accused of helping lead the plot to shoot soldiers at Fort Dix. They are being held without bail. The fact that at least three of the suspects had past run-ins with the law and are in the United States illegally was brought up on Capitol Hill Thursday.

    California congressman Elton Gallegly pointed out Mohammed Atta, one of the Sept. 11 hijackers, was stopped by police for a traffic violation weeks before the attacks. Atta was also in the United States illegally, having overstayed his visa. Attorney General Alberto Gonzales told the panel that many local law enforcement agencies do not check the immigration status of a driver during traffic stops.

    Investigators said the suspects' driving records could be one reason they discussed crashing and exploding tanker trucks into buildings but soon abandoned that idea. The men allegedly went on to try to obtain automatic weapons to attack Fort Dix, officials said.

    Relatives of the southern New Jersey suspects have expressed shock and surprise at the charges. Several of the defendants now have their own lawyers, who said they will fight the charges, raising questions about the FBI's use of an informant.

    The suspects allegedly conducted target practice in the Poconos with four other men. Investigators said those four other suspects were not charged because they apparently played no role in the alleged plot to attack soldiers.

    The six suspects are due in court Friday for their bail hearing.

    The suspects were arrested earlier this week after a 15-month FBI investigation that relied heavily on two paid informants who secretly recorded meetings and telephone conversations in which the suspects talked of killing "in the name of Allah."

    U.S. Attorney Christopher Christie defended the government's handling of the case. He and the FBI portrayed the defendants as Muslim fanatics who were nearly ready to strike. They were arrested Monday night during what the FBI said was an attempt to buy AK-47 machine guns, M-16s and other weapons.

    Former FBI agent Kevin Barrows said prosecutors appeared to have done things right.

    "They corroborated with surveillance, and they had a gun buy set up," Barrows said. "That further solidified the case, as opposed to it just being a tape of somebody saying, `Yeah, I want to buy guns.' They worked this for a long time and the evidence seems really, really solid."

    Prosecutors portrayed the six men -- Serdar Tatar, 23; Agron Abdullahu, 24; Mohamad Ibrahim Shnewer, 22; and the Duka brothers -- as driven by hatred of America, a description disputed by relatives and acquaintances.

    "I never in my wildest dreams imagined what they've been accused of," said Ismail Badat, trustee of the Islamic Center of South Jersey in Palmyra, where the Duka brothers worshipped.

    The same documents that prosecutors used to build a case against the suspects also depict them as somewhat disorganized, lackluster plotters. And clumsy and amateurish, too: The FBI learned of the alleged plot when the men went to a Circuit City store and asked a clerk to transfer a jihad training video of themselves onto a DVD. Also, they mistakenly thought an AK-47 costs $500, instead of $1,500 to $3,000.

    Also, one of the men, Tatar, called a Philadelphia police officer in November, saying that he had been approached by someone who was pressuring him to obtain a map of Fort Dix, and that he feared the incident was terrorist-related, according to court documents.

    "It could be a defense, that he felt he was being pressured to do things and actually called law enforcement to report it," Sohail Mohammed, a lawyer and Muslim community leader in New Jersey who is not involved in the case.

    Entrapment occurs when law enforcement officials entice others into committing a crime they otherwise would not have committed. Under the law, people cannot be convicted if they were entrapped. But there is no entrapment if a person is willing to break the law and law officers offer to help.

    "If the source talks them into committing a crime, that is entrapment," said retired FBI agent Craig Dotlo, a 32-year veteran. But "if they are predisposed to commit a crime, and you give them the opportunity, that's fine."

    Among other things, even before the informant presented the list of weapons he said he could get, Dritan Duka unwittingly asked an undercover federal agent he had seen at a firing range about where he might buy an AK-47 or M-16, according to the FBI.

    Archie, the defense attorney, conceded it is difficult to win an entrapment defense. "Basically, if they are just constantly pushing someone to go in a particular direction," he said. "It's just got to be obvious, obvious entrapment for it to fly."

    Attorney Henry Klingeman unsuccessfully argued that government agents had entrapped London merchant Hemant Lakhani, convicted in New Jersey in 2005. Lakhani was caught in a sting trying to arrange the sale of at least 50 shoulder-fired missiles for shooting down American airliners. He is serving a 47-year prison sentence.

    "In the post-9/11 era, the entrapment defense is basically useless," Klingeman said. "For a defendant, merely saying he wishes he could do harm to America, the jury has heard enough."

    Entrapment also failed as a defense in the case of Shahwar Matin Siraj, who was convicted in New York City of plotting to blow up the Herald Square subway station in 2003. Authorities had recruited an Egyptian man as an informant.

    Siraj's lawyer, Martin R. Stolar, argued at trial that Siraj had no interest in violence until the informant showed him photos of prisoners being abused at Abu Ghraib and told him it was his duty as a Muslim to retaliate. Siraj was found guiity and sentenced to 30 years.

    "The government often overreaches in its zeal to give itself a pat on the back," Stolar said. "In my case, my position was that they created the crime in order to solve the crime so that they could then claim a victory in the war on terror."

    Vincent Henry, director of the Homeland Security Management Institute at Long Island University and a 21-year veteran of the New York Police Department, said he is convinced that the Fort Dix defendants really were capable of pulling off such an attack.

    "I'm sure they were," he said. "The arrests were made as they were on their way to purchase the weapons, or at least some of the weapons. They had seemed to plan it out very, very well."

    IMAGES IN THE NEWS

    Sponsored Links




    Links We Like

    Sponsored Content
    If you suffer from Rheumatoid Arthritis you need to find the right treatment options to prevent joint damage and control pain. More

    Quality landscaping can do more than just make your home beautiful, it can also add to its resale value. More

    Don’t bother with the hassle of trying to sell your car by yourself. Get the help and resources you need to sell your car the easy way here. More

    Learn about the signs, symptoms of ADHD and get information on how to treat it in this helpful guide. More

    Like online video? Then you'll love Now See This.

    Links We Like includes a selection of information, tools and resources from our partners and sponsors.

    Consumer Info


    Sponsored Content Provided by ARA